Pier 95 Restaurant & Marina

The only word I can use to describe the food tonight is exquisite. The service was great, my water glass was never empty and the courses came out well spaced. Staff was incredibly kind and attentive. Our whole party was raving about their food choices and the experience as a whole. I'm not a review kind of person but I felt compelled considering what an a fantastic meal we had

Service was excellent all around. Wait staff is actually quite funny and entertaining. Wish I could remember the name of the head waiter. He was the highlight of the day. Food was fine. Shrimp in a garlic sauce appetizer was the best part of the meal. View from the main dining room was beautiful. Overall it was a pleasant experience.

Considering I had been here a few times prior with my fiancé, I was highly disappointed tonight. It was a very unpleasant experience for my friend Victor and myself. Firstly, Tom the waiter, long black hair, tan complexion, was extremely rude to us. Walked away and turned his back on us while I was in the middle of asking a question, on a second occasion I asked Tom when the kitchen closed, because we had planned on ordering dessert. Tom looked annoyed, snarled, and said to me “Why are you asking?” I was dumbfounded by the response of the waiter, to answer my question with another question. Completely unprofessional. Walked around looking unfriendly and mean, not approachable in the least. When I reached over to take the check from Tom, he dropped it in front of me and couldn’t stretch over to hand it to me. The bus girl Sarah was more pleasant and kind during the small interactions we had with her during our meal. Secondly, the food was ghastly and appalling. I ordered the Filet of Sole, it was chewy and falling apart at the seams. It tasted like rubber and I sent it back, which of course Tom was annoyed about. Then, I ordered the Filet Magian and that was absolutely disgusting. It was burnt on the outside and in the middle, the potatoes were rock solid and had zero flavor whatsoever. Overall, it was a very unpleasant experience from the other experiences I’ve had here before. Will not be returning due to Tom’s arrogance and annoyance with his guests and the food. Highly disappointed with our experience.